Celestron OAG - cannot achieve round stars in guider port Schmidt-Cassegrain Telescope (SCT) Imagers · Charles Harris · ... · 5 · 227 · 0

Harris48Pod 0.00
...
Can anyone tell me what I'm doing wrong..? I have tried adjusting the prizm and auto guider for a solid hour or more, trying to get round stars/rings.  Stars are round like they are supposed to be with a straight through shot, but with the OAG I cannot find the sweet spot.  Is there one and do I just need to try some more to find it?
Like
xordi 3.82
...
Guiding works w/o perfect star shape, I dont care about.
Like
Harris48Pod 0.00
...
Good to know..sounds like the trend...I will keep chugging along..pictures are good, but was wondering if maybe I was missing some precision...guess not..thx.
Like
poobie 0.00
...
Nope, you're seeing what you should.  the OAG is picking off light from the edge of the image circle, where the spherical aberration is worst.  PHD doesn't care if the stars look funny, though, so no big deal.
Like
Harris48Pod 0.00
...
OK thank you..i will drive on with that in mind...pics are good, just wondering if perfection was something to achieve on this issue.. 8)
Like
Joostie 0.00
...
·  2 likes
Maybe a late reaction but maybe usefull for whoever reads this

The trick which helped me is: drive in the prism in the OAG as far as possible into the optical path - without vignetting the sensor. The deeper it sticks, the more it shadows the sensor, the higher out it sticks, the more light you loose and the more funny your starshapes become.

It really makes a big difference to slide the prism a mm down or not, especially in light. And hence in guiding stars limiting magnitude.
For a DSLR this means positioning the prism on the long side of the sensor.  Doing so, and bringing it to the edge of the sensor without vignetting, will pick up stars inside the corrected field of view circle of the telescope (obviously assuming the DSLR FOV is well corrected). In that case your guide stars will be round!

You can test how deep you can drive the prism visually during daytime while looking through the telescope, through your DSLR or your CCD (on screen in the latter case).

When you have found that deepest prism spot, lock the prism location. Then slide the OAG camera along the prism bar to find the focus.
This can be done during daylight unless you're using a Lacerta e.g.

Clear Skies  8)

Joostie
Like
 
Register or login to create to post a reply.